Home > academia, sports > It’s Time to Cancel College Football

It’s Time to Cancel College Football

I love football. My husband Pete played right guard and defensive end in high school, and a picture of him in his uniform (#67) is on my dresser. Pete and I were season ticket holders for The Atlanta Falcons for more than a decade. Before that, we were season ticket holders for the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets. I was commissioner of a fantasy football league for more than a decade. I love football, but I have mostly given it up, because it is hurting our athletes.

The evidence is unmistakable: football players can develop traumatic brain injuries decades later, even if they never had a concussion. The NFL agrees that a third of former players will develop serious brain injuries. In 79 brains of former players studied by the nation’s largest brain bank, 76 had traumatic brain injuries. Suicides among former players suffering from brain injuries are rising.

When our oldest son was born, Pete and I had several conversations about whether we would let him play football. Pete showed me his slightly crooked left pinky finger, noted that a jammed finger was his only real injury, and argued that the sport is perfectly safe at the high-school level. That was ten years ago. These days, with every new news report about chronic traumatic encephalitis (CTE), he cowers. He is worried that all those hits as a lineman will catch up with him—and he only played through high school. Not the big hits, but the accumulation of small hits. When our now 11-year-old begged to join a rugby team this fall, it was Pete who said no.

Every time this topic comes up, the phrase “an inconvenient truth” comes to mind. The facts are extremely inconvenient. But the evidence is so clear at this point that it seems irresponsible to continue with the status quo. At minimum, it’s time for major rule changes. But I’m skeptical that rule changes can fix the problem. I’m wondering if it’s time for us to cancel football. Especially college football. As a university, our mission is to nurture our students—to help prepare them for productive and healthy lives as members of society. All of our students—including members of our football team. Can we really say right now that we are putting their best interests first?

Pro football players are adults, and they make their own choices. But in college football, the students have been put in our care. Our responsibilities as a university are different.

Yes, I know what I’m suggesting would cause a firestorm of unprecedented proportions. Yes, I know the alumni will riot. But should we refuse to do the right thing because it’s inconvenient or unpopular?

I admire Chris Borland, who left the NFL after one year out of concern for his health. I admire my colleague Janet Murray, who turned down an invitation to be guest coach for our football team because she feels the damage the sport is doing to our students’ long-term health is unjustifiable. She explained this in a letter to our football coach. More people need to stand up. It’s time for things to change.

It seems likely that over the next several years a series of high-profile lawsuits will lead to multi-million dollar judgments for former players, both college and pro. I wouldn’t buy stock in a company that insures NFL teams. As a state school, Georgia Tech typically doesn’t buy insurance—we self insure, or rely on our sovereign immunity from lawsuits. I don’t understand the legal nuances here, but I wonder what’s going to happen. If state sovereign immunity holds up in court, will our former players get no compensation? If it doesn’t hold up, will we have fewer science labs and student lounges because all our money is going to cover football liability? Neither option is appealing.

After the first round of lawsuits, no doubt the rules of football will be changed to make it safer. I’ll speculate that a few years later, there will be more lawsuits saying, “Sorry, we’re still getting hurt.” And then the rules will change more. And onwards, until eventually the game will be unrecognizable from what it is today. But do we really need to let this whole process take decades? Given that the end seems inevitable, can we speed things up a bit by doing the right thing now?

Georgia Tech’s mission statement says, “We will be leaders in improving the human condition in Georgia, the United States, and around the globe.” I hope we have the courage to lead on this issue. It would certainly make a statement if we said, “We are cancelling football, because it’s not safe.” We can have our homecoming celebration at a basketball or baseball game. They are also fine traditions.

We gave up our NFL season tickets this year, and I don’t play fantasy football any more. I do sometimes still watch Falcons and Yellow Jackets games on television, but feel guilty even about that.

To everyone reading this, especially my fellow faculty members at Georgia Tech, and others schools: If you agree, I hope you’ll say something. Publicly. We need all of us to speak up, if change is to happen sooner rather than later. Before another generation of players suffer the consequences.

Categories: academia, sports Tags:
  1. Tom C.
    November 9, 2015 at 5:06 pm

    > …begged to join a rugby team…

    I wouldn’t assume that the same effects apply to rugby players. Playing without protective equipment means that players hit and tackle one another quite differently. It would be better to learn how rugby players fare in later life and base a decision on that information.

    • November 9, 2015 at 5:25 pm

      Totally agree, Tom. We’re still not letting him play, because we really just don’t know. I would need affirmative evidence that it’s safe. But you’re right that it’s not fair because we don’t really know!

      • Tom C.
        November 9, 2015 at 10:42 pm

        And if it was my child, I’d likely do the same thing.

  2. James Landay
    November 10, 2015 at 12:49 am

    Do you know if Rugby has the same problem? They tend not to use their heads to hit and tackle low.

  3. November 10, 2015 at 12:56 pm

    Rugby appears to be much safer than football. Someone just sent me this link:

    I’m still not sure if we’re comfortable letting N play, and I’d love to see more evidence!

  4. Aaron Massey
    November 11, 2015 at 4:09 pm

    Related: The US Soccer Federation just banned headers for US soccer players prior to age 11. This change came as the result of a lawsuit, and they are also changing a few other related rules, like substitution rules to allow for concussion protocols and recommended limits for headers in practice for ages 11 to 13.

  5. January 1, 2016 at 4:37 pm

    Another reason for cancelling college football: The costs. https://gasstationwithoutpumps.wordpress.com/2015/12/24/sports-at-any-cost/

    • January 1, 2016 at 8:57 pm

      Uh, yeah. That’s pretty depressing. Thanks for the link.

  6. Marc Martin
    November 16, 2016 at 11:57 am

    My college english class had to write a position paper on this blog/ article, and myself being a collegiate football player realizes our parents worries everyday we go onto that field. That being said we do much more harm to our bodies doing everyday things that limit lifespan, so if your child’s passion is sports such as rugby and football, you shouldn’t limit that child, you cannot limit your child’s future because what makes him happy is dangerous. You cannot stop football because football gives young athletes like myself who grew up in Oakland California with no money opportunities to become successful. We are all entitled to our opinions, yes, but you should think beyond the effects which hit us at the average of 70 years old. when in reality it is only 8 years earlier than a non-athlete. I feel as if 8 years is worth the 16 years of handwork, grind, and happiness i’ve had.

    -Every active ball player

    • November 16, 2016 at 12:29 pm

      Thanks for the comment, Marc. 🙂

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: